Hurtubise Façades Blog

Beyond Aesthetics: Comparing Aluminum Panels and MCM

Written by Maibec | Jun 1, 2023 6:50:31 PM

When it comes to selecting cladding materials, we need to go beyond mere looks and dive into the practical aspects that truly make a difference. In this article, we'll explore why aluminum panels reign supreme over Metal Composite Materials (MCM) in the cladding game. 

The Unrivaled Strengths of Aluminum Panels

Let's kick off with aluminum panels who's strengths make them the superheroes of cladding materials. First up, durability! Aluminum panels are like the Hulk of the cladding world, with their exceptional resistance to corrosion, rust, and decay. They can handle anything Mother Nature throws their way, from fierce storms to salty sea breezes. Say goodbye to worrying about your cladding crumbling away like a poorly constructed sandcastle!

And speaking of weather resistance, aluminum panels laugh in the face of UV rays, extreme temperatures, and moisture. They're like the cool sunglasses-wearing, SPF 100-slathered cladding that shields your building from the elements. You can trust that your project will stay in tip-top shape while other claddings wilt under the scorching sun or turn into soggy messes during rainy seasons.

But wait, there's more! Aluminum panels have a secret power: fire resistance. They are the fireproof superheroes that protect your building from turning into a blazing inferno. With aluminum panels, you can sleep soundly, knowing that your cladding will act as a shield against the flames. It's like having a team of firefighters on duty 24/7, ready to tackle any fiery situation.

Now, let's talk about the incredible strength-to-weight ratio of aluminum panels. They are the featherweight champions of the cladding world, making installation a breeze. Say goodbye to back-breaking construction work! It's like having a cladding material that's as light as a unicorn's mane but as strong as Thor's hammer. You can save time, money, and your poor construction crew's aching muscles.

MCM: So Close and Yet So Far

Alright, now let's turn our attention to MCM panels and shed some light on their weaknesses. Picture this: MCM panels are like the sidekicks who tried to step into the spotlight but stumbled along the way. One of their biggest weaknesses is moisture infiltration. These panels can end up being like leaky buckets, allowing water to seep in and wreak havoc. Warping, delamination, and decay can become their not-so-cool party tricks. If you don't want your building to turn into a water park, you might want to reconsider MCM panels.

Water infiltration in MCM panels can occur through various pathways, primarily due to the design and construction characteristics of these panels. Here are some common ways water can infiltrate MCM panels:

  1. Panel Joints: MCM panels are typically installed with joints between each panel. These joints can become potential entry points for water if they are not properly sealed or if the sealant deteriorates over time. Water can seep through these gaps and find its way into the underlying layers of the panel.
  2. Edge Conditions: The edges of MCM panels, where they meet windows, doors, or other building components, are particularly vulnerable to water infiltration. If the edges are not adequately protected or sealed, water can penetrate the panel system through these vulnerable points.
  3. Fastener Penetrations: MCM panels are often attached to the building structure using fasteners. If the fastener penetrations are not properly sealed or if the fasteners corrode over time, water can enter the panel system through these openings.
  4. Improper Installation: If MCM panels are not installed correctly, with proper flashing and detailing, water can find its way into the panel system. Improper installation techniques can create gaps or openings that allow water to infiltrate.
  5. Panel Damage or Deterioration: Any damage to the surface of MCM panels, such as cracks, chips, or holes, can provide pathways for water infiltration. Additionally, over time, the protective coatings or finishes on the panels may deteriorate, making them more susceptible to water penetration.

Once water infiltrates the MCM panels, it can migrate through the layers of the panel system, leading to issues such as warping, delamination, and decay, as mentioned earlier. It's crucial to address these vulnerabilities during the design and installation stages and ensure proper maintenance to prevent water infiltration and its associated problems.

Oh, and let's not forget about the limited lifespan of MCM panels. They're like the short-lived mayflies of cladding materials. Over time, their core materials deteriorate faster than milk left out in the sun. And that means expensive repairs or even complete replacement. It's like getting a cladding material with a built-in expiration date. Not exactly the kind of investment you want for your project, right?

We can't ignore the fire vulnerability of MCM panels either. They're like the flammable sidekicks that have a habit of catching fire at the worst possible moments. Their combustible core materials can turn a small spark into a full-blown blaze. If you don't want your building to become a fire-breathing dragon, it's best to steer clear of MCM panels.

Conclusion

Aluminum panels have proven to be the superheroes of the cladding world, offering unmatched durability, weather resistance, fire resistance, and lightweight construction.  Their durability, weather resistance, fire resistance, and lightweight yet robust construction make them the unrivaled champions of the game. With aluminum panels, you can have a cladding material that not only lasts but also keeps your building safe and sound.Meanwhile, MCM panels have revealed their weaknesses in moisture infiltration, limited lifespan, and fire vulnerability.

Join satisfied architects and builders in embracing the power of aluminum panels. Contact Maibec for superior cladding solutions that create timeless architectural masterpieces. Choose aluminum panels for unrivaled quality and endless possibilities. Elevate your designs to new heights – take action now!